"Best Source" Discussion set up, thoughts requested

[disco]

I was thinking of a way we could create a forum/thread that would allow people to vote on sources (one vote per source maybe) so that we could construct a tool that automatically rates our favorite tapes by vote. Then we could link to those etree sources or link the ISO forum for requests of said sources. Thoughts?
As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

[Shadowmaster]

As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I am doing this as well, have been working up since 1992....

[nab]

This is sorely needed in the Phish cannon, and this is the best place to do it. 


I fear that any such dialogue may denigrate into minutiae like GD sources. 

[Superfreakie]

As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I am doing this as well, have been working up since 1992....

Jeff Mitchell is doing this as well and has a blog that is running along with it. He started his listening project at 1990.

[AntelopeFreeway]

As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I am doing this as well, have been working up since 1992....

Jeff Mitchell is doing this as well and has a blog that is running along with it. He started his listening project at 1990.

TLTG (Too lazy to google)

Please post link

[disco]

I was thinking of a way we could create a forum/thread that would allow people to vote on sources (one vote per source maybe) so that we could construct a tool that automatically rates our favorite tapes by vote. Then we could link to those etree sources or link the ISO forum for requests of said sources. Thoughts?
As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I was being sarcastic about Mr. Augusto   :-D ....he may be doing that but I'm not looking for someone to go back, just a place for us to record things moving forward.
I know the db will keep all the sources, what I'm looking to do is have a vote system (or something) that allows us to rate sources so that someone can swoop in, see the recommended sources and link right to said torrents.

[mistercharlie]

I was thinking of a way we could create a forum/thread that would allow people to vote on sources (one vote per source maybe) so that we could construct a tool that automatically rates our favorite tapes by vote. Then we could link to those etree sources or link the ISO forum for requests of said sources. Thoughts?
As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I was being sarcastic about Mr. Augusto   :-D ....he may be doing that but I'm not looking for someone to go back, just a place for us to record things moving forward.
I know the db will keep all the sources, what I'm looking to do is have a vote system (or something) that allows us to rate sources so that someone can swoop in, see the recommended sources and link right to said torrents.

I would love an organized database of source recommendations! I've never been one to 'collect' every availiable source. I'll grab every source, and then keep the one that pleases me most, but It'd be better to see other peoples recommendations and save myself the time and bandwidht of getting all the seeding sources.

[mehead]

I was thinking of a way we could create a forum/thread that would allow people to vote on sources (one vote per source maybe) so that we could construct a tool that automatically rates our favorite tapes by vote. Then we could link to those etree sources or link the ISO forum for requests of said sources. Thoughts?
As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I was being sarcastic about Mr. Augusto   :-D ....he may be doing that but I'm not looking for someone to go back, just a place for us to record things moving forward.
I know the db will keep all the sources, what I'm looking to do is have a vote system (or something) that allows us to rate sources so that someone can swoop in, see the recommended sources and link right to said torrents.

I would love an organized database of source recommendations! I've never been one to 'collect' every availiable source. I'll grab every source, and then keep the one that pleases me most, but It'd be better to see other peoples recommendations and save myself the time and bandwidht of getting all the seeding sources.

[Shadowmaster]

I was thinking of a way we could create a forum/thread that would allow people to vote on sources (one vote per source maybe) so that we could construct a tool that automatically rates our favorite tapes by vote. Then we could link to those etree sources or link the ISO forum for requests of said sources. Thoughts?
As a side note, G. Augusto has agreed to go back and listen to all sources of phish that exist and post links to etree links for said shows that he will totally like seed foreva and shit.

I was being sarcastic about Mr. Augusto   :-D ....he may be doing that but I'm not looking for someone to go back, just a place for us to record things moving forward.
I know the db will keep all the sources, what I'm looking to do is have a vote system (or something) that allows us to rate sources so that someone can swoop in, see the recommended sources and link right to said torrents.

I would love an organized database of source recommendations! I've never been one to 'collect' every availiable source. I'll grab every source, and then keep the one that pleases me most, but It'd be better to see other peoples recommendations and save myself the time and bandwidht of getting all the seeding sources.

I was planning on doing it in SQL server 2008. Any help is appreciated. It would work exponentially faster if we all pick years/tours.

[Shadowmaster]

For what it's worth, the Indio shows, the gotfob sources sound best so far. Anyone recommend any others?

[Superfreakie]

Here you go guys. Jeff Mitchell's blog. I think this is the 1990 page. He started it just recently and is making some headway....dude's been busy, 1990 is nearly done.

http://jmitchell20042003.blogspot.com/

[Shadowmaster]

Thanks for the link SF

[Mr Minor]

This would be great.  I have multiple sources of many shows, but would like to trim my collection down to the best one (which may be one I don't have).  I would also love the opportunity to discuss why these recordings are great or not.

This is like the ultimate Week4paug Show Club.

[drvinestein]

I think a "best source" link would be a great addition to the wiki or a "top 3" with how many out of how many votes the particular source got.

Like:
1997-xx-xx
Neumann mics > DAT > FLAC  25 out of 40 votes
Schoeps mics > DAT > CDR > EAC > SHN 13 out of 40 votes

[mattstick]

Here you go guys. Jeff Mitchell's blog. I think this is the 1990 page. He started it just recently and is making some headway....dude's been busy, 1990 is nearly done.

http://jmitchell20042003.blogspot.com/

Jeff loves my Fall '90 remasters  :-D