12/31 - Madison Square Garden - New York, NY - Post-Show Discussion and Review

[Gundo]

Best band ever!

[JPhishman]

Yeah Phish

[Undermind]

Yeah Phish

[anthrax]

just got home - what a night :rockout:  glad to see/meet so many of you.  pics coming soon.

IRON MAN  :rawk: :rawk: :rawk: :rawk: :rawk:

[Thrillhouse]

just got home - what a night :rockout:  glad to see/meet so many of you.  pics coming soon.

IRON MAN  :rawk: :rawk: :rawk: :rawk: :rawk:

I saw you in the section over. Good lord were you lovin that!

[anthrax]

just got home - what a night :rockout:  glad to see/meet so many of you.  pics coming soon.

IRON MAN  :rawk: :rawk: :rawk: :rawk: :rawk:

I saw you in the section over. Good lord were you lovin that!

yeah i was!  i looked over and had a clear line of sight to scotty, which was amazing because there was probably 30-40 seats between us.  he shot me the "i love metal" face, and i kept raging.

[jephrey]

Maybe this was discussed in the live thread but just something I saw. It appeared that the encore was supposed to start with summer of 89- trey seemed flustered when everyone else was playing driver.  Or maybe it was him who fucked up.  Driver made sense for golfing but summer of 89 would have been a good lead into ironman IMO.

[WhatstheUse?]

Maybe this was discussed in the live thread but just something I saw. It appeared that the encore was supposed to start with summer of 89- trey seemed flustered when everyone else was playing driver.  Or maybe it was him who fucked up.  Driver made sense for golfing but summer of 89 would have been a good lead into ironman IMO.

That's what I heard as well.  I said Summer of 89 to McGrupp and we both that that was kinda weird...

manybe they just totally blanked on how to play driver...

[antelope19]

Maybe this was discussed in the live thread but just something I saw. It appeared that the encore was supposed to start with summer of 89- trey seemed flustered when everyone else was playing driver.  Or maybe it was him who fucked up.  Driver made sense for golfing but summer of 89 would have been a good lead into ironman IMO.

That's what I heard as well.  I said Summer of 89 to McGrupp and we both that that was kinda weird...

maybe Trey just totally blanked on how to play driver...

FYP

To me, it sounded like everyone else was playing Driver except Trey.

[rowjimmy]

Maybe this was discussed in the live thread but just something I saw. It appeared that the encore was supposed to start with summer of 89- trey seemed flustered when everyone else was playing driver.  Or maybe it was him who fucked up.  Driver made sense for golfing but summer of 89 would have been a good lead into ironman IMO.

That's what I heard as well.  I said Summer of 89 to McGrupp and we both that that was kinda weird...

maybe Trey just totally blanked on how to play driver...

FYP

To me, it sounded like everyone else was playing Driver except Trey.

I heard Driver.
Trey didn't seem to remember how to play it but That's what I heard.

[nab]

Maybe this was discussed in the live thread but just something I saw. It appeared that the encore was supposed to start with summer of 89- trey seemed flustered when everyone else was playing driver.  Or maybe it was him who fucked up.  Driver made sense for golfing but summer of 89 would have been a good lead into ironman IMO.

That's what I heard as well.  I said Summer of 89 to McGrupp and we both that that was kinda weird...

maybe Trey just totally blanked on how to play driver...

FYP

To me, it sounded like everyone else was playing Driver except Trey.

I heard Driver.
Trey didn't seem to remember how to play it but That's what I heard.

Same here, though people I was watching the webcast with heard Summer of 89.

[mbw]

Maybe this was discussed in the live thread but just something I saw. It appeared that the encore was supposed to start with summer of 89- trey seemed flustered when everyone else was playing driver.  Or maybe it was him who fucked up.  Driver made sense for golfing but summer of 89 would have been a good lead into ironman IMO.

That's what I heard as well.  I said Summer of 89 to McGrupp and we both that that was kinda weird...

maybe Trey just totally blanked on how to play driver...

FYP

To me, it sounded like everyone else was playing Driver except Trey.

I heard Driver.
Trey didn't seem to remember how to play it but That's what I heard.

Same here, though people I was watching the webcast with heard Summer of 89.

proud that i wouldnt know what that sounded like if i heard it.

[mattstick]

Some people were suggesting that was done on purpose, like a mulligan...

Seems like a stretch to me.

[PIE-GUY]

Gothamist with a great review of the show including some great pictures... here's my favorite of the bunch:



full review here:

http://gothamist.com/2013/01/02/photos_video_phish_stage_nye_runawa.php#photo-1

[mattstick]