Abbey Road Region - 5-Bob Dylan v 12-Frank Zappa

[sls.stormyrider]

wow - this is getting close

[anthrax]

2 words

JOE'S GARAGE

[susep]

tough vote but I went w/ the key of Z

Zimmerman?


:wink:

[fauxpaxfauxreal]

I voted Dylan and I'm pleasantly surprised that Zappa isn't destroying this category.

[Multibeast12]

Very Close. But gotta go with Frank on this one. Frank is the man and will always be.

[Hicks]

Zappa is cool and all, but Dylan pretty much invented modern rock lyric writing, so it would be a travesty if he lost in round 1 IMO.

[sls.stormyrider]

Ha - we agree on something
:-)

[rowjimmy]

2 words

JOE'S GARAGE

I hate that record.

Zappa is cool and all, but Dylan pretty much invented modern rock lyric writing, so it would be a travesty if he lost in round 1 IMO.

Exactly.
We'd all still be considering the profundity of "I Wanna Hold Your Hand" were it not for Mr. Dylan.

[JPhishman]

tough call but Zappa gets much more play time from me.

[zimbra]

tough call but Zappa gets much more play time from me.

This was exactly the same logic I used to decide.

[qop24]

only on a phish site would this be a tie

[ytowndan]

only on a phish site would this be a tie

It was a pretty easy decision for me, but I knew that collectively as a group, this would be a damn close one.   

[guyforget]

im breaking the tie @ 19 w/ a vote for dylan

[rowjimmy]

* rowjimmy locks the voting while Dylan is ahead...

[PIE-GUY]

2 words

JOE'S GARAGE

I hate that record.

If Joe's Garage is why you like Zappa, then great. But you really need to listen to some more Zappa. It's definitely my least favorite Zappa album.