Nice, small place to see them.
That pic reminds me of Stabler Arena in Bethlehem, PA.
Bowie - Badass opener! That's how you start a Phish career! 1 minute intro is all they need. Composed sections are good. Trey begins the jam with some cool octave playing a la Wes Montgomery. Brief modulation ~6 minutes in. The band is listening really well to one another and they turn into the outro section all super tight-like.
Bouncing - Trey sounds a little out of tune, but you might have been too much of a n00b to know that this is a bathroom song anyway.

Heart - I'll grant Page the winner of this solo competition.
Ice - Straight nailed. Is that Trey rubbing a bottle against the strings during the break?
Glide - Crowd loves it! They didn't know it when Fish was playing the beat the whole time, but they sure knew it when Mike and Trey came in! Trey is slightly out of tune again.
Rift - Mike drops some SER balmz at the end during the "shocked me" vocals.
Stash - Some nice meat. Real thrashy version. Page let's er'one know that the aisles must be cleared! Fist DE gig!
Lawn - Cool Trey solo, but I'm a fan of Mike's these days.
Maze - Playful intro thanks to Fish. Trey's solo is quite blistery. Liking the flow of this set.
Golgi - Little out of tune, but whatevs after that Maze solo. Tight set.
Jim - Great opener and really fiery. Crowd is supra pumped and still
with the band.
Wilson - Slightly extended intro. 3 Secret Language calls throughout. Really liked this version. One of the more "open" ones I've heard.
UPenn - Some more bluegrass to showcase their chops.
Tweezer - More meats! Really enjoyed the Uncle Ebineezer section. Even if Trey came in one tone lower than he meant to, it still worked out well. They get right to the jam. Major key modulation ~5:20. This part
almost reminded me of the Red Rocks 'o9 version for a second. Great tension before the band gets dark at 8:55. NIce one.
Lizards - Great placement and played well.
Llama - Bringing it back up with some more Gamehendge stuff. Equal parts noise and shrage. Trippy vocal stylings at the end.
YEM - Great composed sections. Cool rhythmic break around twelve minutes in. Lion Sleeps Tonight vocal jam.
BBJ - Your only, too?
Length - Pretty rowdy with the crowd still singing and Fish on the vac. Took me until 2010 to see my first.

Coil - Trey comes in like a 13 year old all crackly on the vox.
Cavern - The Other Set Closer.
Grace - For the showcase win.
Reprise - Nice and fast.
Overall, great show and an even better FIRST show!
Lotsa heavy hitters and a great mix of tunes to showcase/sell the band to the newer peeps.
I give it an A.