Favorite One-Off cover of 3.0

[WhatstheUse?]

What say you, fellow Paugers? I'm probably forgetting a bunch but... oh well!

Let's exclude Halloween tunes. That gets complicated. Same with acapella tunes...

[WhatstheUse?]

Okay, I'll start.

Everything in Its Right Place got my vote. It's cringeworthy upon Relisten but I've never been more psyched on a new cover... at the time.

Sunday Morning was special.

Instant Karma and Free Man in Paris were tunes I was unfamiliar with before seeing them live - then became obsessed, primarily with the Phish versions.

Rocket Man brings back especially fond memories. As does Iron Man (spotting Anthrax halfway across the venue ROCKING the fuck out - Devil horns ensued)

Once in a Lifetime stands out as the most cringe worthy moment I recall.... they just... did not play it well.

[mattstick]

It's Powderfinger. Brought me to tears.

[PIE-GUY]

I was on the verge of voting for Instant Karma - I was right next to  when they busted that out and we were both grinning ear to ear... but Monkey Man gets my vote. That tune is so gritty, and they fucking nailed it. It's one of my favorite 3.0 moments, honestly.

[WhatstheUse?]

I was on the verge of voting for Instant Karma - I was right next to  when they busted that out and we were both grinning ear to ear... but Monkey Man gets my vote. That tune is so gritty, and they fucking nailed it. It's one of my favorite 3.0 moments, honestly.

I have vivid memories of asking you what they were playing!

[PIE-GUY]

I was on the verge of voting for Instant Karma - I was right next to  when they busted that out and we were both grinning ear to ear... but Monkey Man gets my vote. That tune is so gritty, and they fucking nailed it. It's one of my favorite 3.0 moments, honestly.

I have vivid memories of asking you what they were playing!

I have a vivid memory of hearing the opening chord and immediately and knowingly singing along with Page on the opening line "Instant Karma's gonna get you"

[susep]

I go back to Free Man in Paris quite often.  The way Phish plays it reminds of the Allman Bros. 
White Winter Hymnal is another gem.   

[anthrax]

BIG BALLS!!!!!!!!!  (But I voted Monkey Man)

[mbw]

I vote O Holy Night.

How in the fuck had you never heard Instant Karma??

[Buffalo Budd]

Where's my 'Killing In the Name'?!
My mind went there immediately.

[mopper_smurf]

Where's my 'Killing In the Name'?!
My mind went there immediately.

QFT

[cactusfan]

Thank you for reminding me about Monkey Man. Listened to that for the first time in forever. Good one.

But. I voted for Night Nurse.

Also--it's Way Down in the Hole. Not "Whole." Though that's not a bad name for a song.

And isn't Suffragette City part of a halloween show?

[mistercharlie]

It's Powderfinger. Brought me to tears.

This is the correct answer. But,.....

Where's my 'Killing In the Name'?!
My mind went there immediately.

This is me also.

[anthrax]

Killing in the Name was by far my most favorite one to see live, followed by Iron Man.  However, I've listened to Monkey Man more than any other 3.0 cover.

Great poll, WTU!

[mistercharlie]

Killing in the Name was by far my most favorite one to see live, followed by Iron Man.  However, I've listened to Monkey Man more than any other 3.0 cover.

Great poll, WTU!