Week4paug Phan Pick 25

[whatapiper]

so eventually i would like to organize a little 25 show project based on the top 25 picks of our community here at week4paug.   i will keep track for a few weeks to let everyone have a chance to get a list together.  im not sure what would be easier, picking 10, 15, 25 shows. so i guess just start a list, if you have 15 shows you really think should be on the list go for it, and if you think of only a few, go for it.   this is just a random idea that came about by the recent poll disco started in pbtp.

[sophist]

here's my favorite 10: (not top 10  :wink: )
01) 12/7/97
02) 11/28/97
03) Day 1 Clifford Ball
04) 11/21/97
05) 11/23/97
06) 12/6/97
07) 12/31/95
08) 12/31/99
09) 10/31/96
10) 06/19/04

[McGrupp]

6/11/94
12/31/99
11/17/97
12/11/99
12/14/95
12/31/93
7/10/97
8/16/93
2/28/03
8/17/97

[jedifunk]

wondering if i might hijack this topic... as we start to delve deeper into the wiki project, we would like to get feed back on a variety of things from our group here at the paug...

one of those being our top 25 favorite/best shows...  so i'll be monitoring this thread and will gleen info from it...

in time i will also post topics for things such as top 5 from a particular tour; hidden gems (lesser talked about); dark horses (underrated); etc.

so fire away...

/end hijack/

[susep]

7May91
31Dec.91
18April92
1Dec.92
30Dec.93
13Aug.93
26Nov.94
31Oct.94
8Dec.95
29Dec.95
Clifford Ball Flat Bed Jam
31Dec.96
21Nov.97
10July97
3Aug.98
2July98
15July99
17Sept.99
12Sept.00
30June00

2Jan.03
3Aug.03
15April04
15Aug.04

[fauxpaxfauxreal]

Here's my top 25 in sequential order.

1.)November 02, 1990
2.)March 16, 1991
3.)July 14, 1991
4.)August 3, 1991 
5.)October 13, 1991   
6.)October 31, 1991    *********
7.)March 20, 1992      **********
8.)April 18, 1992       ***********
9.)April 19, 1992 (I'm still searching for a replacement copy if anyone has the shns and can seed it pretty pretty pretty please )
10.)November 19, 1992
11.)February 20, 1993 **********
12.)March 14, 1993
13.)March 22, 1993   ***********
14.)March 30, 1993
15.)August 9, 1993
16.)August 13, 1993  ***********
17.)Dec 30, 1993 *********************
18.)June 18, 1994
19.)June 22, 1994 ******************
20.)July 13, 1994
21.)October 22, 1995
22.)November 14, 1995 ***************
23.)December 31, 1995 **************
24.)October 31, 1996   ****************
25.)June 25, 1997

12 of the shows I thought merited AUTOMATIC inclusion in anyones top 25 shows...so I starred them with asterisks (I almost asterisked big birch too, because I think it deserves it...but I didn't want to go overboard:)

This is definitely a good thread.  I can't wait to see how it pans out!

[sls.stormyrider]

2/20/93
8/28/93
12/30/93
6/18/94
12/9/95
12/31/95
12/6/96
11/22/97
11/28/97
4/3/98
12/30/99
12/31/99
2/28/03
6/19/04

[justjezmund]

Top 15
1. 8-9-93
2. 8-13-93
3. 4-4-94
4. 6-26-94
5. 8-16-96
6. 11-19-96
7. 12-6-97
8. 12-9-97
9. 12-13-97
10. 8-3-98
11. 11-6-98
12. 2-21-03
13. 2-28-03
14. 12-2-03
15. 6-17-04

[VA $l!m]

before this goes any further, can someone clarify whether this is a top favorite shows thread, or what one considers to be the top shows of all time thread?

thanks.

[Hicks]

As I understand it, it's an attempt to come to a consensus of our top 25 shows of all time.

But if a show is your favorite then I wouldn't hesitate nominating it, and who knows maybe it will make the cut.

Do guys think we should disqualify any official releases because of availability?  Just an idea.

Here's mine:

11/23/85
8/21/87
5/28/89
3/13/92
4/16/92
2/20/93
8/2/93
8/7/93
12/30/93
12/31/93
6/26/94
7/13/94
12/29/95
8/16/96
12/6/96
8/17/97
11/21/97
11/22/97
12/11/97
12/30/97
12/31/98
12/31/99
8/3/03
12/29/03
6/19/04

[sophist]

before this goes any further, can someone clarify whether this is a top favorite shows thread, or what one considers to be the top shows of all time thread?

thanks.

I did my favorite, but I guess that was wrong.  So shall I consturct a top 1o show list?

[Hicks]

before this goes any further, can someone clarify whether this is a top favorite shows thread, or what one considers to be the top shows of all time thread?

thanks.

I did my favorite, but I guess that was wrong.  So shall I consturct a top 1o show list?

The way I see it, the more suggestions the merrier.   :-)

[cactusfan]

my favorite 22 shows, i.e. the shows i listen to the most, the shows i just couldn't live without, the shows that move me the most. plus, one reason for the presence of each because, well, why not?

11.14.95-- stash

2.17.97-- carini
7.1.97-- slave
7.29.97-- antelope
8.2.97-- soam
8.16.97-- cities
11.26.97-- set II
11.28.97-- timber
12.3.97-- gumbo -> 2001
12.6.97-- tweezer
12.7.97-- tube

4.3.98-- roses are free
7.2.98-- shafty
7.15.98-- moma dance
10.31.98-- oh! sweet nuthin'

9.11.99-- wolfman's -> sand
9.12.99-- theme from the bottom
10.2.99-- on your way down

6.9.00-- tweezer
6.14.00-- set II

2.28.03-- tweezer
7.30.03-- twist

[whatapiper]

thanks for all the feedback!!  to clarify, this is all about your top picks of all time.  the more the merrier is right, like i said, this will be up for a bit to try and get the most out of these picks.  if you need to add a show, go for it.

right now in no particular order

99/12/31
97/12/07
97/11/21
97/11/22
04/06/17
93/12/30
96/08/16
96/08/17
95/12/31
97/08/13
island tour
98/08/09
97/08/17
97/12/30
98/11/02
97/11/28
98/11/27
97/11/29
98/08/03
97/12/09
00/09/30
96/10/31
94/07/16
94/12/29
97/11/17
94/07/08
............................

this is tough, im going to be revising this one, these were off the top of my head so i want to make sure my list is accurate.  these picks are interesting b/c you really get a sense for what type of fan we all are.

[Itsnotanexperience]

7/22/97
3/22/93
4/17/92
12/6/96
12/11/99
6/26/04
7/29/98
7/23/97
11/17/97
12/28/95
12/29/95
11/12/94
4/3/98
7/1/97