7 - John Coltrane - A Love Supreme v 10 - Phish - Junta

[rowjimmy]

vs a whole buncha beepin and boppin.

You poor, misguided, soul.

i was merely trying to reduce the album to one silly, unfair comment, kinda like a record about creepy dolls and weasels.

I said it had songs about creepy dolls and weasels. That's a fact.

how do you feels about the music behind those and other songs on the album?

I like them. There are clever and interesting compositions on that album. They also link to some nice memories.

But they don't have the force of emotion I feel in A Love Supreme.

A Love Supreme is an album that changed the way I looked at the world as well as music.

[twatts]

vs a whole buncha beepin and boppin.

You poor, misguided, soul.

i was merely trying to reduce the album to one silly, unfair comment, kinda like a record about creepy dolls and weasels.

I said it had songs about creepy dolls and weasels. That's a fact.

how do you feels about the music behind those and other songs on the album?

I like them. There are clever and interesting compositions on that album. They also link to some nice memories.

But they don't have the force of emotion I feel in A Love Supreme.

A Love Supreme is an album that changed the way I looked at the world as well as music.

I we really having this discussion???  I mean I loved my first car, I took it to the beach and many road-trips and lost my virginity in it...  But comparing it to a Ferrari is bordering on absurdity...

Terry

[rowjimmy]

vs a whole buncha beepin and boppin.

You poor, misguided, soul.

i was merely trying to reduce the album to one silly, unfair comment, kinda like a record about creepy dolls and weasels.

I said it had songs about creepy dolls and weasels. That's a fact.

how do you feels about the music behind those and other songs on the album?

I like them. There are clever and interesting compositions on that album. They also link to some nice memories.

But they don't have the force of emotion I feel in A Love Supreme.

A Love Supreme is an album that changed the way I looked at the world as well as music.

I we really having this discussion???  I mean I loved my first car, I took it to the beach and many road-trips and lost my virginity in it...  But comparing it to a Ferrari is bordering on absurdity...

Terry

Sha-blammy

h/t to barnesy

[mbw]

you guys all have mccoy tyner tix for the dc show in april, right?

[Buffalo Budd]

It seems unfair for A Love Supreme to be in this tournament.

So true.

[rowjimmy]

you guys all have mccoy tyner tix for the dc show in april, right?

I can't afford that shit. But this isn't a McCoy Tyner live experience poll, is it?

Also, no Phish tickets.

[Hicks]

Whateves, I'm not gonna vote for an album I've listened to 20 times over an album I've listened to hundreds of times to gain credibility or because the music snob bible says I "should".

[rowjimmy]

Fuck bibles, do it because, in your heart, you know it's right.

Honestly, though, it's the musicians in here who have the most credibility at stake.

[Hicks]

Fuck bibles, do it because, in your heart, you know it's right.

Honestly, though, it's the musicians in here who have the most credibility at stake.

This guy's heart says Junta loud and clear.

ETA:  I hope everyone thinks about this thread as they are standing in line at the crack of dawn tingling with anticipation as they wait for a copy of said record w/ songs about weasels and rag dolls.

[twatts]

Fuck bibles, do it because, in your heart, you know it's right.

Honestly, though, it's the musicians in here who have the most credibility at stake.

This guy's heart says Junta loud and clear.

ETA:  I hope everyone thinks about this thread as they are standing in line at the crack of dawn tingling with anticipation as they wait for a copy of said record w/ songs about weasels and rag dolls.

Says the guy that laughed at me liking Van Halen I...   :-P

Terry

[rowjimmy]

Fuck bibles, do it because, in your heart, you know it's right.

Honestly, though, it's the musicians in here who have the most credibility at stake.

This guy's heart says Junta loud and clear.

ETA:  I hope everyone thinks about this thread as they are standing in line at the crack of dawn tingling with anticipation as they wait for a copy of said record w/ songs about weasels and rag dolls.

I already have a perfect copy of A Love Supreme on vinyl.

[DoW]

it's funny because I thought of the whole vinyl anticipation during this thread as well.

the reality is that I'm not a huge beatles fan but I'm voting for abbey road over junta if it came down to that.  but on some votes, I am going with my favorite.

these conversations always go down the same road.  is it best?  is it favorite?
a lot of these votes have me  :shakehead: but it has led to a lot of good conversation on here.

when you think about it, there are no classical albums in this tourney.  my knowledge is so lackluster in that area.  I wanted to add that in the mix but I just don't have that knowledge base to do it.

I really have no point but to agree and disagree at the same time with everyone and no one.

[Hicks]

Fuck bibles, do it because, in your heart, you know it's right.

Honestly, though, it's the musicians in here who have the most credibility at stake.

This guy's heart says Junta loud and clear.

ETA:  I hope everyone thinks about this thread as they are standing in line at the crack of dawn tingling with anticipation as they wait for a copy of said record w/ songs about weasels and rag dolls.

Says the guy that laughed at me liking Van Halen I...   :-P

Terry

Uh, pretty sure I was referring to you preferring Diver Down over Van Halen I.

[mbw]

you guys all have mccoy tyner tix for the dc show in april, right?

I can't afford that shit. But this isn't a McCoy Tyner live experience poll, is it?

Also, no Phish tickets.

Just a funny way to treat a guy who was instrumental, pun intended, in changing the way you see life.
you've seen him live though, right?

[gah]

It seems unfair for A Love Supreme to be in this tournament.

So true.